New -- Social Golfer Combinations
Downhill & Uphill Putts
How
much harder do you need to hit an uphill putt? How much softer
do you need to hit a downhill putt? This page will answer those
two questions.
Similar to the spreadsheet I've created to model golf ball trajectories, I've also created one the models how a ball rolls over the surface of a green. Using this, I take into account the speed of the green (stimpmeter reading) and the slope of the green (in degrees that can be measured using a BreakMaster Green Reader).
Here are the results for a uphill putt on a 1.0 degree slope with a stimpmeter reading of 12 ft (quite fast).
Slope |
Distance |
Speed |
Normal |
|
(ft) |
(ft/s) |
(ft) |
|
|
|
|
1.0 |
5.0 |
4.50 |
6.7 |
1.0 |
10.0 |
6.36 |
13.2 |
1.0 |
15 |
7.80 |
19.7 |
1.0 |
20 |
9.00 |
26.2 |
1.0 |
25 |
10.07 |
32.7 |
1.0 |
30 |
11.03 |
39.2 |
1.0 |
40 |
12.74 |
52.2 |
1.0 |
50 |
14.25 |
65.2 |
1.0 |
60 |
15.61 |
78.1 |
1.0 |
80 |
18.02 |
103.9 |
The 'Distance' column displays the physical distance to the hole. the 'Speed' column displays the ball speed required to travel that distance uphill. The 'Normal' column displays how far the ball would roll given the speed on a level green (0 degree slope).
So, a 20 footer uphill would need to be struck with enough speed so that it would travel 26.2 feet on a level green. Thus, one would want to aim about 6 feet past the hole on this uphill putt.
Here are the results for a downhill putt on a 1.0 degree slope with a stimpmeter reading of 12 ft (quite fast).
Slope |
Distance |
Speed |
Normal |
|
(ft) |
(ft/s) |
(ft) |
|
|
|
|
-1.0 |
5.0 |
3.33 |
3.7 |
-1.0 |
10.0 |
4.80 |
7.6 |
-1.0 |
15 |
5.95 |
11.6 |
-1.0 |
20 |
6.90 |
15.5 |
-1.0 |
25 |
7.74 |
19.5 |
-1.0 |
30 |
8.51 |
23.5 |
-1.0 |
40 |
9.86 |
31.4 |
-1.0 |
50 |
11.05 |
39.4 |
-1.0 |
60 |
12.15 |
47.5 |
-1.0 |
80 |
14.07 |
63.5 |
Note the 'Slope' column indicates negative 1.0 degree, the negative meaning downhill.
A 20 foot putt would need to be struck downhill with enough speed so that it would travel 15.5 feet on a level green. Thus, one would want to aim 4.5 feet short of the hole on this downhill putt.
I've replicated this analysis for different sloped greens and for different speed greens (slow, medium, fast, stimpmeter) and written the results up as one of my useful golf tips.
The tips will give you an easy routine to follow to determine how much longer (uphill putts) or shorter (downhill putts) your putts will play, thus taking the guess work out of your putting stroke.
Knowing how far a putt will play will enable you to putt with more confidence. And, as you probably know, amateurs 3 putt way more often than pros, not because they under read the amount of break, but because they either come up way short or way long.
You can order my putting procedure here for $19.99 by clicking the PayPal Logo.
You can purchase the putting procedure, reading and playing the wind & reading and playing elevation changes for $39.99 by emailing me at probablegolf@yahoo.ca
Calculation Method
To analyze
and uphill and downhill putt, it is easiest to use conservation
of energy. Do you remember your junior science or your high school
physics? In any system of objects, total energy is conserved.
Once a putt is struck, it has kinetic energy. That energy is transformed
into thermal energy due to friction as the ball rolls along the
grass. On very fast greens, friction is small thus a putt rolls
a long ways before all of its kinetic energy is transformed into
thermal energy. For a flat putt, the conservation of energy equation
would be:
kinetic energy
before = thermal energy after
0.5mv*v
= Fd
where m is
the mass of the ball, v is the initial speed, F is the frictional
force and d is the distance the ball rolls (the * symbol represents
multiplication). The frictional force, F, is equivalent to:
F
= µmg
where µ
is the coefficient of friction that depends on the roughness
of the surfaces and g is the acceleration of gravity (9.8
m/s2 or
32 ft/s2).
Hubbard and Alaways measured µ between golf balls and
putting greens in a study called "Mechanical Interaction
of the Golf Ball", published in Science and Golf III,
proceedings of the World Scientific Congress of Golf (p.429-439).
Some
of their
results are in the table below.
Stimpmeter Distance (ft) |
7.5
|
8.5
|
9.5
|
10.5
|
Rolling Friction µ |
0.075
|
0.066
|
0.059
|
0.053
|
Combining
the two above equations yields:
0.5mv*v
= µmgd
which simplifies
to:
0.5v*v
= µgd
and thus
the distance a putt travels depends on the inital speed of the
ball, µ and g.
d
= 0.5v*v/ µg
A stimpmeter
gives a golf ball and inital speed of about 6 ft/s. If a ball
is rolling up a hill, then there is another energy transformation
of kinetic energy into gravitational potential energy. Thus, on
an uphill putt, the conservation of energy equation would be:
kinetic energy
= thermal energy + grav energy
0.5mv*v
= Fd +
mgh
0.5mv*v
= µmgd +
mgh
0.5v*v
= µgd +
gh
where h
is the vertical height gained by the ball. Because some of the
original kinetic energy of the ball is transformed into gravitational
potential energy, it doesn't roll as far. To compensate, the golfer
must give the ball more kinetic energy. On a flat putt, the ball
would travel a larger distance. On an uphill putt, the extra distance
is translated into height instead. Thus, instead of the extra
energy translating into distance, it translates into height. The
gain in gravitational potential energy is equal to the extra distance
the ball would travel on a flat surface. Thus,
µmgd =
mgh
µgd =
gh
µd =
h
d
= h/µ
When putting
uphill, the ball must have extra speed comparable to travelling
an extra distance on a level surface. That extra distance equals
the height gained divided by the coefficient of friction. On
a
medium speed green (stimpmeter = 9.5), a putt that rises one
foot must be hit like trying to knock the ball 17 feet past
the
hole
on a level surface (d = 1 ft/ 0.059). Thus if one has a 20 foot
putt up a 1 foot rise hill, the ball must be hit so that it
would
travel 37 feet on a flat green. A golfer must judge the vertical
rise of the putt and know the green's speed.
Note: A 20 foot putt with 1 foot rise equates to a slope of 3 degrees, which is very steep.
For a 20 foot putt, stimp is 12.5, elevation change is 1 foot, I
would basically need to add 23 feet to my putt (if uphill), making the
total putt length 43 feet. Note this is relative to a fast green with stimp of 12.5.
Now if I have the same 20 foot putt, stimp is 7.5, elevation change is 1
foot, I need to add ONLY 13 feet to my putt (if uphill), making the total
putt length only 33 feet. Note that this is relative to a slow green with stimp of 7.5, not to a different speed such as a 12.5 stimp. On fast greens, the relative difference is greater than on slow greens. This is one of the reasons fast greens are more difficult.
On a downhill
putt, the situation is reversed. One would need to try to hit
the ball 17 feet short of the hole for the same scenario as above.
One would play a 20 foot putt as a 3 foot putt. That's why on
many downhill putts, especially on fast greens, it's difficult
to stay short of the hole.
©Probable Golf
Instruction, Ken Tannar 2001-2015. All Rights Reserved.
Langley, B.C. V2Y 2G4 Canada
Phone: 604-309-7030 FAX: to fax, email an attachment
probablegolf@yahoo.ca or golfexpert@probablegolfinstruction.com
|